- The Huddle
- Posts
- The Huddle - Edition 37
The Huddle - Edition 37
A weekly newsletter from The Coaching Dad.
The Coaching Dad
March 13, 2025
Intro
This Week’s Focus: Coaching to Win vs. Coaching to Develop
Every youth sports coach faces an important question: Are you coaching to win or coaching to develop? The best teams are built through strong fundamentals, smart decision-making, and confidence-building experiences, but in the heat of competition, it’s easy to focus only on short-term success—winning the next game, executing a single strategy, or relying on your best players.
The reality is that coaching for development leads to winning in the long run. The goal of any youth coach should be to teach skills, encourage growth, and help athletes build resilience. If done right, winning will follow.
This week’s newsletter takes a deep dive into balancing competition and player development, introduces a hockey drill focused on quick stops and directional changes, and provides coaching tips on reinforcing skill progression throughout the season.
Please share this newsletter with a parent or coach. Encourage them to sign up. It’s a small ask, but it can have a big impact on helping us grow this really awesome community.
Follow us on the social channel of your choice (click on icons at the end or search @the_coaching_dad) and visit www.thecoachingdad.com.
Lets go!
Insight of the week
Winning vs. Development: Striking the Right Balance
Stat to Know:
A 2023 survey by Good Sports revealed that 56% of parents are concerned about affording youth sports next year, highlighting financial strain as a significant barrier to participation.
Introduction: Why Your Coaching Identity Matters
Winning and development are not mutually exclusive, but for many youth coaches, the pressure to win often overshadows the importance of player growth. A short-term focus on winning at all costs can lead to overuse of top players, neglecting skill-building, and discouraging less-developed athletes from participating fully.
On the other hand, prioritizing development doesn’t mean ignoring competition. Instead, it means focusing on long-term improvement so that your players stay engaged, build confidence, and ultimately become stronger athletes—which, in turn, leads to more wins over time.
1. Short-Term vs. Long-Term Success
Coaching to Win: Prioritizes immediate success—relying on top players, using quick-fix strategies, and making decisions based on game results rather than development.
Coaching to Develop: Focuses on building a strong foundation, ensuring that all players improve—even if it means short-term sacrifices in the win column.
Balanced Approach: When players build strong fundamentals and learn the right way to play, competitive success follows. The key is to teach athletes how to play the game properly, rather than simply finding ways to win now.
2. Playing Time: Balancing Fairness & Competition
Younger Players (Ages 4-9): At these ages, the focus should be on maximum participation—players should get equal playing time, allowing them to develop confidence and experience.
Older Players (Ages 10-15): At this stage, playing time can be earned through effort, skill, and attitude. However, all players should still get opportunities to contribute and develop, even if some play more in critical game moments.
The takeaway: Even in competitive settings, development-focused coaching ensures that players of all levels feel valued, motivated, and excited to improve.
3. Teaching Game IQ Over Rote Strategy
Coaches who focus only on winning today might lean on a few strong players to control the game. But in the long run, this limits the entire team’s growth.
Instead, focus on teaching players how to think for themselves:
When to pass vs. take a shot.
How to recognize and adapt to game situations.
The importance of spacing, positioning, and smart decision-making.
The more athletes understand the game, the better they will perform in future competitions.
4. Encouraging Mistakes as a Learning Tool
Players who are afraid to fail won’t take risks, which means they won’t push themselves to improve.
Teach them to view mistakes as part of growth, not something to be feared.
Use phrases like: “What can we learn from that?” rather than “You can’t make that mistake.”
Players who feel comfortable making mistakes will grow into confident, resilient athletes.
5. Defining Success Beyond the Scoreboard
Winning is only one way to measure success—coaches should also track:
How many players improved their skills by season’s end.
How many gained confidence in their abilities.
How many want to return next season because they love the game.
The best coaches don’t just build winning teams—they build athletes who continue to grow long after the season ends.
Drill of the week
Quick Stop
Sport Focus: Hockey
Skill Focus: Quick Stops and Directional Changes
In hockey, the ability to stop and change direction quickly is essential for maintaining control, reacting to plays, and staying defensively sound. This drill improves edge control, balance, and reaction speed, making players more agile on the ice.
Basic Version – "Quick Stop Challenge"
Objective: Teach players to stop efficiently and change direction without losing speed.
Setup:
Set up four cones in a square (about 15 feet apart).
Players begin at one corner of the square.
Execution:
On the whistle, the player skates forward to the first cone.
At the cone, they perform a two-foot hockey stop, then quickly pivot in the opposite direction.
Repeat at each cone until they complete the square.
Coaching Points:
Keep knees bent and weight low for stability.
Ensure controlled stops—players should avoid sliding out of position.
Emphasize quick transitions between stopping and accelerating.
Advanced Version – "Reactive Stop & Go Drill"
Objective: Develop reaction time by making stops and direction changes unpredictable.
Setup:
Similar setup as the basic drill, but the coach calls out commands instead of following a set pattern.
Execution:
Players skate in a random pattern within the cones.
The coach calls out "STOP!" and players must immediately perform a hard stop.
The coach then calls out a new direction ("left," "right," "backward," etc.), and the players react accordingly.
Key Coaching Points:
Players must keep their heads up and react quickly.
Encourage explosive acceleration after each stop.
Reinforce balance and stability to avoid loss of control.
Coaching tip of the week
Balancing Competition & Development Throughout the Season
Introduction: The Big Picture of Success
Success in youth sports isn’t just about the win-loss record. While competition is an important part of the experience, true success is measured by growth, confidence, and player engagement. A team that improves steadily throughout the season—both individually and collectively—will naturally become more competitive.
Coaches should focus on building strong fundamentals, teaching resilience, and fostering a love for the game rather than just chasing victories. The best seasons are those in which players leave more skilled, more confident, and eager to return the next year.
Here’s how to maintain the right balance between developing players and keeping the team competitive:
1. Set the Tone Early
The culture you establish at the very first practice will set expectations for the entire season.
Emphasize Progress Over Perfection: Let players know that their effort, attitude, and improvement matter more than the scoreboard. Players should feel comfortable making mistakes, learning from them, and trying again.
Create Team Values: Develop a set of guiding principles with your team. Examples include:
Work hard and have fun.
Encourage teammates and communicate positively.
Focus on getting better, not just winning.
Celebrate Effort and Small Wins: Recognize hustle plays, players who push through challenges, and moments of improvement—not just goals, baskets, or home runs.
Example: Instead of saying “Great job winning today!”, reframe it as “I loved the way we supported each other and worked as a team—that’s why we played so well!”
2. Reinforce Learning Moments in Every Game & Practice
Every game and practice presents opportunities for growth—even losses.
Use Guided Reflection: After games, ask players questions to help them analyze their performance:
“What did we do well today?”
“Where can we improve?”
“What’s one thing you learned from this game?”
Highlight Small Victories: Skill development happens in small increments. Instead of focusing only on the final score, celebrate moments such as:
A player making a smart decision on the field.
A struggling athlete executing a new skill successfully.
The team communicating and working together better than before.
Example: If a team loses but improved their defensive positioning, the coach should highlight that growth instead of focusing on the loss. “We stayed in position much better today than last game, and that’s going to help us going forward!”
3. Rotate Positions in Practices to Build Versatile Players
Even if players have primary positions in games, giving them exposure to different roles in practice makes them more well-rounded athletes.
Younger Players (Ages 4-9): Let players try multiple positions, as early specialization can limit development. Encourage fun exploration of the game.
Older Players (Ages 10-15): While players may have designated roles, periodically rotating positions builds game IQ and adaptability.
Why It Matters:
Helps players understand the full game better.
Reduces frustration when players are asked to step into a new role during a game.
Prevents burnout by giving variety to practices.
Example: A soccer player who normally plays forward should practice some defensive drills to learn how to defend better. A baseball outfielder should occasionally take ground balls in the infield to improve reaction time.
4. Balance Playing Time Between Development & Competition
Younger Athletes (Ages 4-9): Ensure all players get fair playing time to build confidence and experience.
Older Athletes (Ages 10-15): While competition is more structured, find ways to get every player meaningful minutes—whether starting or coming off the bench.
If players see that effort, improvement, and team contribution lead to more opportunities, they will stay motivated and engaged.
Example: If a player has worked hard in practice, find a way to get them involved in key moments of a game, even if they are not the most skilled player on the team.
5. Track & Celebrate Individual Progress
Keep a “Growth Board” at Practice: Write down small wins each week, such as:
Sophia made her first successful left-handed layup!
The team completed 15 consecutive passes in a scrimmage!
Use Development Check-Ins: Ask players throughout the season:
“What’s a skill you feel better about now than you did a month ago?”
“What’s one goal you want to achieve by the end of the season?”
By tracking progress and celebrating small achievements, players gain confidence and see their hard work paying off—which is key to keeping them engaged in sports.
Blog highlight
The Importance of Youth Athletes Playing Multiple Positions
We explore why playing multiple positions is beneficial, how it positively impacts player development, and strategies coaches can use to implement position rotation effectively.
Equipment highlight
BUCKETSQUAD
Bucketsquad is more than just a brand—it’s a lifestyle for athletes and fans who bring passion to the game. Offering premium, USA-made apparel that combines style, comfort, and durability, empowering you to express yourself on and off the court. With high-quality outdoor basketballs built for performance and gear designed for those who live and breathe the game, Bucketsquad helps you elevate your game in every way.
Friends of The Coaching Dad
Bleacher Prepared
How many of you have spent hours sitting on a cold, hard bench while you watch those that you love battle it out on the field/court? If you’re like me, you’re back hurts after about 20 minutes, not to mention how uncomfortable things can get for your backside! Sitbax has the BEST bleacher seat available, and you have 2 opportunities to get yourself one.
The first is a free giveaway promotion happening through the month of March. You will need to follow both The Coaching Dad and @sitbaxbleacherseats on Instagram. Then comment on the promotional reel that they have posted to their channel OR comment on any of The Coaching Dad “Sitbax Bleacher Series” reels with an @ tag of someone you think needs one.
Your second opportunity to get one of these amazing seats is to visit their site linked below and take advantage of 15% off using the code COACHINGDAD15.
Content
Free Content
You might be new to coaching a team or sport. You may be a grizzled coaching veteran. Either way, check out the content section of thecoachingdad.com. You’ll find resources that cover a large number of sports, including game refreshers, position breakdowns, injury management, practice ideas and more.
Engage
Email Us
Did you miss a previous newsletter? Do you have a topic you’d like us to cover? Looking for broader insights on a particular topic? Send us an email at [email protected]
