The Huddle - Edition 91

Intro
The “Elite” Label Isn’t the Finish Line

If you’ve ever watched tryout week turn into a family stress test, you’re not alone. Youth sports has a way of making normal parents feel like talent scouts and normal kids feel like they’re one bad weekend away from “missing their shot.” And the word that seems to cause the most panic is elite.

Here’s the grounding truth: being on the “elite” team at 9, 11, or even 13 doesn’t come with a guaranteed future. It can be a great environment for the right kid at the right time—but it’s not a direct pipeline to high school varsity, college, or beyond. Development is messy, kids mature at different rates, and opportunities change a lot from year to year.

A few research anchors to keep this conversation honest (without the money side of it):

• The Aspen Institute’s Project Play has reported that the average child spends less than three years playing a sport and quits by age 11, most often because it “isn’t fun anymore.” That’s a useful reminder that early labels don’t matter much if the kid doesn’t stick with the sport.

• The American Academy of Pediatrics has cited that about 70% of youth athletes drop out of organized sports by age 13, and connects dropout to issues like burnout/overtraining and the overall youth sports environment.

• NCAA probability data (last updated April 1, 2024 methodology) shows how selective the pipeline is from high school to NCAA participation. That doesn’t mean “don’t dream”—it means early sorting is a weak predictor and long-term development is what matters.

• Sports medicine research on specialization consistently flags higher degrees of early specialization as a risk factor for overuse injury (and often burnout), which matters when families feel pressured to “pick the elite path” early.

Please share this newsletter with a parent or coach. Encourage them to sign up. It’s a small ask, but it can have a big impact on helping us grow this really awesome community.

Follow us on the social channel of your choice (click on icons at the end or search @the_coaching_dad) and visit www.thecoachingdad.com.

Lets go!

Insight of the week
How Coaches Keep Players Grounded (Even in “Elite” Environments)

Whether you coach the top team in your club or you coach the team that didn’t get the shiny label, your job is the same: build kids. The tricky part is that “elite” can quietly shift the culture from development to identity. Players start to believe their value is tied to a roster, parents start to chase status, and coaches feel pressure to justify the label with constant results.

The best way to keep kids grounded is to keep the standard clear and the message consistent: we’re here to improve and compete, not to attach our confidence to a label.

A few practical ways to do that:

• Coach “habits” more than hype
  Pick 4–6 habits that travel across every level (effort on defense, communication, response after mistakes, first touch/ball security, teammate support). Track those habits weekly and talk about them after wins and losses. That keeps the spotlight on controllables.

• Tell the truth about development out loud
  Say it early in the season and say it again when tryouts approach: kids develop in waves. The best player at 12 isn’t always the best at 16. Roles change. Confidence changes. Bodies change. When a coach says this calmly, it lowers the temperature for everyone.

• Create “growth lanes,” not “status tiers”
  If a player wants to move up, give them a specific plan: “Here are the three skills that will make the biggest difference for you in the next 8 weeks.” That turns ambition into action instead of anxiety.

• Protect the love of the game
  When kids quit early (and both Project Play and AAP have pointed to how common dropout is), it’s often because the experience stops feeling fun and starts feeling like pressure. A grounded team culture keeps intensity without making kids feel trapped.

• Make rest and recovery part of being “serious”
  A lot of the specialization discussion exists because people confuse “more” with “better.” Medical groups have repeatedly cautioned that early, intense single-sport focus can raise overuse injury risk and burnout, and that diversification/rest is often healthier for developing athletes.

Grounding doesn’t mean lowering expectations. It means keeping expectations tied to growth—so kids can chase high standards without turning youth sports into a constant audition.

The Coaching Dad Recommendation
Have a Freshman/Sophomore?? Pay Attention!

If your family wants to make the recruiting process feel less chaotic, Athlete Narrative is a strong recommendation that I love! What stands out is how clearly it supports both sides of the process: it helps athletes stay visible and organized, while also giving parents a better way to stay informed without adding pressure.

For athletes, the biggest value is speed and simplicity. Athlete Narrative highlights a quick-build Radar Page (profile) where athletes can share highlights, stats, grades, and key info in one place, plus tools for school research and coach outreach. They also promote fast communication features like personalized coach emails in under 60 seconds and AI support, which can help athletes stay consistent with outreach instead of putting it off. (athletenarrative.com)

For parents, the value is peace of mind and visibility. Their messaging consistently emphasizes “Parent-Approved Efficiency,” with a focus on saving time, reducing stress, and helping families stay aligned during recruiting. You can also set up weekly parent updates, which is a helpful benefit for families who want to support the process without hovering over every step. (athletenarrative.com)

A big bonus for families following The Coaching Dad: you can access Athlete Narrative at a 40% discount—just $15/month. That’s a fraction of the cost compared to many recruiting services on the market, while still giving families a premium, athlete-first experience.

Drill of the week
Overthrow Backup Drill

Sport: Softball/Baseball

Skill Focus: Hustle awareness, backing up bases, preventing extra bases on overthrows

Setup:

• Use the infield (full field if you can).

• Put players at 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, LF and RF. Add a catcher/coach at home to feed balls.

• Coach has a bucket of balls near home or the mound.

How to Run It:

• Start with routine throws that become intentional “overthrows”.

• Run it in three quick phases so kids learn the responsibility for each base:

  • Overthrow at 1st: throw past 1B → RF backs up 1B and keeps it in front.

  • Overthrow at 2nd: throw past 2B → SS backs up 2B (behind and slightly toward CF).

  • Overthrow at 3rd: throw past 3B → LF backs up 3B (your team rule for this drill).

• Rotate positions every few reps so everyone learns the “backup jobs.”

Coaching Tips:

• Teach one simple habit: the throw is never the end of the play—everyone moves on release, not after it gets by.

• Praise the sprint and positioning: “That backup saved a base” is the exact lesson you want to stick.

Tip of the week
Parents: What “Elite” Usually Means (and What It Doesn’t)

A lot of parents hear “elite” and assume it means: better future. More doors open. Faster path to high school/college. Sometimes it can be a strong environment—better training, stronger competition, more motivated teammates. But in many organizations (especially at younger ages), “elite” often means something simpler: that group is ahead right now, for that club, based on that tryout day, with that coach’s preferences.

Here’s the mindset shift that helps families breathe:

• Elite is a snapshot, not a forecast
  Youth sports is full of early bloomers and late bloomers. Some kids look “behind” at 11 and fly past peers at 14–16 when coordination, strength, and confidence catch up.

• The best question isn’t “Are we elite?” it’s “Are we improving?”
  If your athlete is learning, getting meaningful reps, and gaining confidence, they are not falling behind—regardless of the label on the jersey.

• Your child’s “edge” is often consistency, not status
  Kids who steadily practice fundamentals, compete, and stay coachable over years tend to separate. The families who stay calm usually win the long game.

• Beware the fear-based story
  If the messaging feels like “pick now or you’ll miss your chance,” that’s a red flag. The AAP’s dropout/burnout conversation is a reminder: pressure-heavy environments don’t always produce better athletes—they often produce athletes who are done early.

• Multi-sport and rest don’t mean “less serious”
  Early specialization is not a guaranteed advantage and can carry real risk. For many kids, varied movement, seasons of rest, and different coaching voices can actually make them better athletes long-term.

If your child wants to chase higher levels, awesome—support it. Just don’t let a youth label convince your family that development has a single doorway. It doesn’t.

Blog Highlight
Are Kids Falling Behind If They’re Not on the “Elite” Club Team?

Worried your child is falling behind because they’re not on the “elite” club team? This blog breaks down why early team labels don’t predict high school or college success, and what actually matters more for long-term athlete development—reps, confidence, great coaching, and keeping the love for the game.

Gear up
Start Looking the Part!

Every week I release new products in my Etsy store. My goal is to bring a little style back into the youth sports game. You’ll find things for coaches, parents and kids.

The Volunteer Coach Academy
Stop Guessing and Really Help Your Team Improve

You’ve seen the tips and tools I share each week—now imagine everything you need to coach with confidence, all in one place. I’ve built a complete course designed specifically for volunteer and parent-coaches to help you feel prepared, supported, and ready to lead. Whether you’re stepping on the field for the first time or just want to get better for your kid’s sake, this course was made for you.

Oh and if you aren’t ready for the course yet, still check out the link to learn more because there’s a free Coach’s Guide that you can start using instantly.

Book highlight
For Coaches, Parents and Youth Athletes

The Constant Coach

Get this for the coach in your life as it provides coaching guidance and insights one day at a time throughout the entire year.

Stories For Young Athletes

Do you have an Young athlete who’s afraid of getting hit by a pitch or who maybe isn’t quite as aggressive on the soccer field as they could be? This book helps kids with a variety of circumstances, in a lot of different sports, through various stories that your child can relate to. It’s perfect for kids 7-11!

Featured Coaching Resources
Aggression and Anxiety Guides

I just released two new guides designed to make your coaching easier and your players more confident:

1. The Aggression Guide
Perfect for the child who plays great at home but hesitates in games. This guide gives you simple, practical strategies to help players be more assertive, engaged, and confident—without pressure or yelling.

2. Calm Under Pressure
A quick, powerful guide for helping young athletes manage anxiety, nerves, and fear of mistakes. You’ll learn what to look for, what to say, and how to support kids during tough moments.

Content
Other Free Content

You might be new to coaching a team or sport. You may be a grizzled coaching veteran. Either way, check out the content section of thecoachingdad.com. You’ll find resources that cover a large number of sports, including game refreshers, position breakdowns, injury management, practice ideas and more.

Engage
Email Us

Did you miss a previous newsletter? Do you have a topic you’d like us to cover? Looking for broader insights on a particular topic? Send us an email at [email protected]

Newsletter Sign Up
Those not already receiving The Huddle, click below. You can also access previously published newsletters from this link.